For Weeks now we’ve been hearing about two MVP candidates in
the NFL; Adrian Peterson, and Peyton Manning. Let me first start off by saying
that Adrian Peterson is my MVP. He single handedly carried the Vikings into the
playoffs with a season that most won’t forget anytime soon—finishing only 9
yards short of the single season rushing record. Now that I’ve got that off my
chest, let’s talk about Aaron Rodgers.
Peyton Manning had a great year. There’s no question about
it, but the fact that Rodgers isn’t even being mentioned when the “Who should
be the MVP” talks come up in the sports world is mind-boggling. It’s even
evident in the All-Pro voting which was released earlier this morning. Manning
received 43 votes while Rodgers received only 4. It’s a shame no one is taking
notice of Rodgers MVP caliber numbers.
Looking at the stats suggest these are two pretty even
quarterbacks. Manning has thrown for 37 touchdowns, 11 interceptions, 4,659
yards—in 583 attempts, and a 68.6% completion percentage. On the other hand,
Rodgers has thrown for 39 touchdowns, 8 interceptions, 4,295 yards—in 552
attempts, and a 67.2% completion percentage. Rodgers also had a passer rating
(108.0 to 105.8). Not to mention Rodgers’ mobility both inside and outside the
pocket.
I’d like to see what Manning would be able to do in Rodgers’
shoes. Manning has the luxury of playing behind one of the NFL’s best offensive
lines, only being sacked 21 times this years as opposed to Rodgers’ 51. Now,
some of those Rodgers sacks are his own fault as he has a tendency to hang on
to the ball too long at times, but the Packers O-line has been abysmal all year.
I can almost guarantee Manning does not put up the same numbers if he had the
Packers’ O-line protecting him, as Peyton doesn’t have the ability to escape
the pocket when things collapse as well as Rodgers can.
If you gave Aaron Rodgers the time in the pocket that
Manning receives, this wouldn’t even be an argument. You would think that the
reigning NFL MVP would be getting a little more love from the hype machine
known as ESPN, but it appears as if they’re putting all their eggs in Peyton’s
basket. It’s almost as if he being penalized because his numbers are down from
perhaps the greatest season by a quarterback ever last year. But make no
mistake, Aaron Rodgers still put up MVP caliber numbers this year.
I completely agree with you. I never understood why only AP and Peyton were brought up in the MVP talk. AP separated himself from the other RB's whereas Peyton did not separate himself from other QB's in the league. I don't know how he is any more valuable than other elite QB's. It is pretty amazing Rodgers, hasn't gotten more love, for it to be 43 to 4 in All-Pro voting is just ridiculous.
ReplyDelete